Since scooters landed in Austin, unfortunately people have encountered dangers of riding them to get around town. Unfortunately Austin did see its’ first scooter related fatality in early February when UT exchange student, Mark Sands, died in a car-scooter accident along the I-35 frontage road.
Scooter injuries are unfortunately a possible risk while traveling on the motorized vehicle. Now it’s time to take a look at how officials, individuals, and companies can each play a role in keeping our streets safe from scooter injury. Read on to see how scooters can be used safely and legally across the city.
Scooter Regulation News Across the State
Over the past year we’ve watched the city of Austin and others scramble to regulate the dockless scooters dropped by startups. Meanwhile, downtown dwellers are showing up in flocks to ride scooters to every destination in and out of downtown. Unfortunately, the headlines have lead with regulatory efforts less often than with headlines reporting injury – oftentimes serious.
And now, the CDC will be studying the health impacts of dockless electric scooters – and the study will take place in Austin.
Read on to find out more about speculation (and likely outcomes) for the latest in personal injury law: personal injury scooter and accident claims.
Injury Lawsuits in Austin Allege Negligence on Part of E-Scooter Companies
An Austin attorney filed seven lawsuits during the week of July 11, 2019 reports KXAN News. The lawsuits were filed against Lime, Bird, and Jump.
In these cases, some aspect of the scooter was defective. In these cases, the attorney has said the he was sure that user error was not a factor. In most of these cases the user has experienced some level of impairment.
There is a unique hurdle for all of the cases: the user agreements make it tough for users to have their cases heard outside of California.
The suits also mention the recent Centers for Disease Control epidemiological study about scooters in Austin, which found that nearly 200 people were injured in scooter-related accidents. The researchers found that nearly 1/2 of people had a severe injury and of those, 20% went to the hospital.
The lawsuits arose when the Austin lawyer determined that the scooter companies had no intention to settle. The clients named seek monetary recovery to help cover the costs of their medical bills due to the scooter accident.
Dallas Senator Attempts to Regulate Scooters at State Level
April 25, 2019
Dallas Texas State Senator Royce West has proposed legislation that would provide some regulations on scooters across the state. After the senator saw two people try to ride one scooter at the same time, he started looking at regulations that would promote safety for riders and other road users.
Under the bill proposed by the Democratic Senator, cities maintain most control over how to regulate use of scooters in the municipality. A city or county may prohibit the operation of a motor-assisted scooter on a street, highway or sidewalk for safety reasons. The county or city can choose to restrict the age of e-scooter operators, related speed limits, and parking limits.
What the law specifies that the state would prohibit is:
- Prohibit more than one person at a time from riding an e-scooter.
- Require riders to be at least 16 years old
- Restrict scooters to ride on bike paths or roads whose speed limits are 35 mph or less
- Limit the speed of stand up scooters to 15 mph, and 20 mph for sitting scooters
- Prohibit e-scooters from riding on sidewalks, and disallow any parking of a scooter that causes an obstruction to other road users
After the bill was filed in January, it has been endorsed by a Senate committee according to the Dallas Morning News.
December 2018 | CDC Conducts Study of Scooter Injuries in Austin
Are scooters safe? CDC is conducting a study about scooters may be a convenient way to travel, and with growing popularity the CDC wants to know if they are safe. A team of CDC epidemiologists will investigate the circumstances in which individuals sustain injuries while traveling on scooters. They’ll propose ways for users and transportation officials to prevent injuries.
The 90-day study will focus on EMS calls and emergency room data related to scooter crashes.
When the study’s results are made available in the spring, city officials will know more about where the scooters should be ridden and how to regulate them.
In the user agreement for Bird Bikes, a rider is required to file a police report for injuries within 24 hours if personal injury occurs.
1.12 Reporting of Damage or Crashes. Rider must report any accident, crash, damage, personal injury, stolen or lost Vehicle, to Bird as soon as possible. If a crash involves personal injury, property damage, or a stolen Vehicle, Rider shall file a report with the local police department within 24 hours. Rider agrees that he/she is responsible and liable for any misuse, consequences, claims, demands, causes of action, losses, liabilities, damages, injuries, costs and expenses, penalties, attorney’s fees, judgments, suits or disbursements of any kind or nature whatsoever related to a stolen or lost Vehicle.
How soon will attorneys be handling litigation involving dockless scooters?
A scramble to regulate the new companies may set some standard for Dockless motorized scooters dropped by two companies – Bird Rides and LimeBike – started posing hazards to pedestrians when the company dropped them on April 16, 2018. Then, in a flash they were all gone. City of Austin officials worked overnight to roll out a plan to regulate the business. They’re avoiding a swamp – and a the treacherous unknown road hazards the scooters (and bikes!) could pose to the city and its’ pedestrians. It’s possible personal injury attorneys could be seeing a new set of cases in Austin, related to the liability scooters and drivers will take on in a new driver-rider landscape.
Scooters left undocked could pose serious danger to pedestrians, especially those that are visually impaired. Blocking sidewalks with a bicycle is already a ticketable offense in the city of Austin. But what happens when those bikes are dockless, not owned by the rider, and left in flocks on city sidewalks? If you’re imagining sidewalks littered with motorized scooters, you might be on the same page as Austin’s City Council.
It could be negligent for a company to allow their fleet to clog up roadways causing road hazards for pedestrians. It’ll be up to many in the city Austin to determine where that line will fall. At this time companies vetted by the city are required to carry liability insurance on the riders. But as many new companies entered the market all at once – will all have such precautions?
The scooter saga has really just begun, and several important events unfolded in Austin in the regulation of motorized scooters and bicycles. Recall that Austin already has a rent-to-use bicycle program called Austin B-Cycle. Even so, in spring Austin started a “dockless bike share community forum” as an effort promote cycling and other “active transportation.” The forum, held at the city’s new downtown Austin library, included four-minute pitches. Reps from each free-range bike rental company gave shark-tank style pitches on why riders should rely on them, and the city should choose them in the pilot program. Earlier this year things were going well and looking a lot less complicated for city council.
Texas Officials Struggle to Regulate New Flock of Scooters
Laura Dierenfield, a city official employee who leads the efforts was quoted by the Statesman’s Ben Wear as saying “we’re really focusing on bikes. I don’t see this pilot focusing on scooters.”
Fast forward just a few weeks and that statement sounds ridiculous. Going downtown it’s hard to miss one of the rentable, dockless scooters. Within 2 days of Dierenfield’s statement to the reporter, the city’s focus had been forcefully shifted to attention on scooters. Bird Rides had dropped about 50 black-and-white electric scooters in South Congress, the Zilker area, and East Austin’s entertainment district. And LimeBike had dropped a set of green-white scooters of their own. The city’s response was to let the company’s representatives know that they would impound any scooters that were left to sit in right of way for two days or more.
With scooters already out on the streets, Austin decided to add scooters to the pilot program as well. Estimates say that Bird Rides’ flock of thin scooters had grown to almost 700. But the question of who would be responsible in the event of an accident remains unanswered.
Then on Friday April 27, City Council worked until after 2 a.m. to finalize changes to city code that would prohibit leaving dockless scooters and bikes on sidewalks and streets until a permitting process begins. Violators can face a $200 fine and have the scooter impounded. Companies shouldn’t operate in way that might endanger people by having unsafe streets or sidewalks – such as if a hoard of scooters were left on a busy pathway, tripped individuals or forced them into traffic.
Then, over the weekend, both companies pulled their vehicles from city streets, saying that they expected them to be back again in a few days. The city of Austin did impound about 70 of them before the shuffle. A rep from Birds said they would not be operating outside the boundaries of the Austin ordinance just passed.
Remember that we mentioned Austin’s own B-Cycle program at the start of this article? It was the the first rent-a-bike program in Austin. It was created in Austin, for Austin, and will soon be outnumbered (and likely outpriced) by newcomers in the pilot program. Startups such as LimeBikes, Ofos, MoBikes, Jumps and V Bikes, will be offering a ride for less than the city’s own B-Cycle.
It all sounds too familiar. Recall Uber and Lyft’s messy fingerprinting history with city council, and the vote on Prop 1? Let’s hope, for everyone, that the new and yet-untested market of dockless bicycles and scooters doesn’t go there. It’s now up to city of Austin officials, bike and scooter riders, and the scooter startups to find a solution that will keep the dockless vehicles out of right of way, and out of the harm of blind or otherwise impaired pedestrians.
March 2018 – Bird Drops Dockless Scooters During SXSW Festival for Pilot
Beginning in March 2018 during SXSW Electric scooters became available in the city of Austin. Since then the scooters have expanded to cities across the state. So far the scooters are located in
- San Antonio
… And this is just the beginning. LimeBike, Bird Rides, and a cohort of other dockless vehicle companies have entered Austin. Companies such as LimeBike, which has received funding from corporate giants Uber and Alphabet (the parent company of Google.) Bird
What will these new flocks of motorized vehicles mean for personal injury attorneys, negotiating for injured travelers, mean across the state?